42CrMo4vs4140

AISI 4140 and EN 42CrMo4 (1.7225) are close Cr-Mo equivalents, not identical: Mn 0.75–1.00% vs 0.60–0.90%, Cr 0.80–1.10% vs 0.90–1.20%, tighter P and S limits in EN. Chemistry, Q&T strength and uses side by side.

Chemical composition: where they differ

42CrMo4 (1.7225) is a chromium-molybdenum quenched and tempered steel to EN 10083-3 (now EN ISO 683-2); 4140 is the chromium-molybdenum alloy steel defined in SAE J404 and ASTM A29. They belong to the same family and are often named interchangeably, but their limits are not identical. Carbon is 0.38–0.45% in 42CrMo4 and 0.38–0.43% in 4140. 4140 carries more manganese (0.75–1.00% vs 0.60–0.90%), while 42CrMo4 has slightly more chromium (0.90–1.20% vs 0.80–1.10%) and a wider molybdenum range (0.15–0.30% vs 0.15–0.25%). EN caps phosphorus at 0.025% and sulphur at 0.035%; A29 allows 0.035% and 0.040%. A sulphur-controlled variant, 42CrMoS4 (1.7227), exists for better machinability.

Chemical Composition

Element42CrMo44140
C0.38–0.450.38–0.43
Si≤ 0.400.15–0.35
Mn0.60–0.900.75–1.00
P≤ 0.025≤ 0.035
S≤ 0.035≤ 0.040
Cr0.90–1.200.80–1.10
Mo0.15–0.300.15–0.25

Heat (cast) analysis, % by mass.

Basis: 42CrMo4 — EN 10083-3 / EN ISO 683-24140 — SAE J404 / ASTM A29

Mechanical properties and strength

In quenched and tempered steels, strength is set by heat treatment and section size more than by chemistry. EN 10083-3 gives section-dependent values for 42CrMo4 in the +QT condition: up to 16 mm at least 900 MPa yield and 1100–1300 MPa tensile, 16–40 mm at least 750 MPa yield and 1000–1200 MPa tensile, 40–100 mm at least 650 MPa yield and 900–1100 MPa tensile strength. SAE J404 and ASTM A29 define only the chemistry of 4140; its mechanical values follow the ordered heat-treatment condition, the product standard or the customer specification. That is why the 4140 column of the table is empty. Given the same heat treatment, the two steels deliver very similar strength and toughness; small differences show up in hardenability and can affect core values in heavy sections.

Mechanical Properties

Property42CrMo44140
Yield Strength (MPa)≥ 750—
Tensile Strength (MPa)1000–1200—
Elongation (%)≥ 11—

Basis: 42CrMo4 — +QT · 16 < d ≤ 40 mm · EN 10083-34140 — SAE J404 / ASTM A29

—: the designation sets no value for this property, or no comparable value is given here. The binding value follows the product standard, the delivery condition and the order, and is stated on the inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1).

Heat treatment and delivery conditions

Both steels follow the same route: hardening from about 840–880 °C in oil (polymer for thin sections), then tempering at 540–680 °C depending on the strength required. EN defines the delivery conditions +A (soft annealed), +QT (quenched and tempered) and the hardenability-banded +H, +HH and +HL; in the USA, 4140 is usually ordered as annealed or quenched and tempered (Q&T) bar. Where high surface wear resistance is needed, induction or flame hardening and nitriding can be applied. Molybdenum improves resistance to temper embrittlement, one of the features that sets these grades apart from plain chromium low-alloy steels.

Weldability and machinability

Because of their high carbon equivalent, both grades are regarded as weldable only under controlled conditions: preheating (typically 200–300 °C), a controlled interpass temperature, low-hydrogen filler metal and post-weld stress relieving are required; otherwise the heat-affected zone can harden and crack. Machining is easiest in the soft-annealed condition; in the quenched and tempered condition, cutting speed and feed are reduced as hardness rises. For high-volume turning and drilling, variants such as sulphur-controlled 42CrMoS4 or, on the US side, leaded 41L40 improve productivity.

Typical applications

These two steels are the standard material for heavily loaded machine parts: shafts, axles, crankshafts, gears, high-strength bolts and studs, hydraulic cylinder rods, die holders and forgings. They are also common in oil and gas equipment, valve and pump shafts, flanges and connection parts. The ASTM A193 B7 bolting material used in pressure joints belongs to the same chromium-molybdenum family; there, chemistry and heat-treatment requirements are set by that standard itself.

Applications

  • Shafts, axles and crankshafts
  • High-strength bolts and studs
  • Gears and pinions
  • Hydraulic cylinder rods
  • Oil and gas equipment, flanges and connection parts

42CrMo4 or 4140: which to choose and when

If the drawing or specification is based on EN, order 42CrMo4 (+A or +QT); US drawings and specifications based on ASTM or API call for 4140. Using 42CrMo4 instead of 4140 causes no problem in most applications, but the order should be written to the standard against which acceptance testing will be done. As the section grows, the strength values in EN 10083-3 fall; for large diameters that need high strength right through to the core, the nickel-alloyed 34CrNiMo6 or 4340 should be considered. For lower-cost, smaller-section parts, the non-alloy C45 may be sufficient.

Equivalence caveats and ordering notes

42CrMo4 and 4140 are close counterparts, not exact equivalents. Their manganese, chromium and molybdenum ranges overlap only partly: one heat can satisfy both, but not every heat does. Dual-certified bar meeting both standards is available on the market; in that case, the inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1) must show that the heat analysis falls within both ranges. JIS SCM440 and GB 42CrMo are likewise only approximate counterparts. In the order, state the standard, grade, diameter, delivery condition (+A or +QT), the required strength or hardness range and, if needed, the ultrasonic testing requirement.

Grade Equivalents

System42CrMo44140
EN42CrMo4≈ 42CrMo4
DIN (W.Nr.)1.7225≈ 1.7225
AISI/SAE≈ 41404140
UNS—G41400
JIS≈ SCM440≈ SCM440
GB (China)≈ 42CrMo≈ 42CrMo

Standards

42CrMo4

  • EN 10083-3
  • EN ISO 683-2

4140

  • SAE J404
  • ASTM A29/A29M
  • ASTM A322
  • ASTM A331

The values on this page are reference data compiled from the published limits of the standards named. Binding values are those on the material's inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1), according to the standard and delivery condition stated in the order.

Looking for this steel grade?

Request a quote with your sizes, tolerances and delivery condition — we respond within 24 hours.

Request a Quote