16MnCr5vs5115
EN 16MnCr5 (1.7131) and SAE 5115 share almost the same carbon range, but 16MnCr5 has Mn 1.00–1.30% and Cr 0.80–1.10% vs 0.70–0.90% each in 5115, so hardenability differs. Chemistry, heat treatment, uses and selection.
Chemical composition: where they differ
16MnCr5 (1.7131) is a manganese-chromium case-hardening steel under EN 10084 (now EN ISO 683-3); 5115 is a chromium alloy steel defined in SAE J404 and ASTM A29. The carbon ranges are almost the same (0.14–0.19% vs 0.13–0.18%); the difference lies in the alloying. 16MnCr5 has 1.00–1.30% manganese and 0.80–1.10% chromium, while 5115 has 0.70–0.90% of each. In other words, 16MnCr5 carries both more manganese and more chromium. EN limits phosphorus to 0.025% and sulphur to 0.035%; A29 allows 0.035% and 0.040%. For machinability there is also 16MnCrS5 (1.7139) with sulphur controlled to 0.020–0.040%.
Chemical Composition
| Element | 16MnCr5 | 5115 |
|---|---|---|
| C | 0.14–0.19 | 0.13–0.18 |
| Si | ≤ 0.40 | 0.15–0.35 |
| Mn | 1.00–1.30 | 0.70–0.90 |
| P | ≤ 0.025 | ≤ 0.035 |
| S | ≤ 0.035 | ≤ 0.040 |
| Cr | 0.80–1.10 | 0.70–0.90 |
Heat (cast) analysis, % by mass.
Basis: 16MnCr5 — EN 10084 / EN ISO 683-35115 — SAE J404 / ASTM A29
Mechanical properties and strength
For case-hardening steels the tensile strength as delivered is not what counts; what matters is the surface hardness, case depth and core strength after the part has been carburized and hardened. That is why this page has no mechanical table: SAE J404 and ASTM A29 define chemistry only, and EN 10084 gives hardness limits per delivery condition plus optional hardenability (Jominy) bands. The real difference is hardenability: the higher manganese and chromium of 16MnCr5 give higher core hardness and strength in the same section. In thick-section gears the core of 5115 may stay at lower values.
Heat treatment and delivery conditions
Both steels follow the same route: carburizing (gas carburizing or carbonitriding), then direct, single or double hardening and low-temperature tempering. The result is a hard, wear-resistant surface over a tough core. EN 10084 defines the delivery conditions: +A (soft annealed), +TH (treated to a hardness range), +FP (treated to a ferrite-pearlite structure and hardness range) and the hardenability-banded +H, +HH and +HL. The +FP condition is preferred in particular to improve machinability before gear cutting and to limit distortion in carburizing.
Weldability and machinability
Thanks to their low carbon, both grades can be welded before carburizing; carburized and hardened surfaces should not be welded. Machining is done in the annealed or +FP condition; for gear hobbing and broaching, sulphur-controlled 16MnCrS5 is an advantage. After hardening, usually only grinding and precision finishing remain.
Typical applications
Medium-duty gears, pinions, splined shafts, piston pins, camshafts, chain components and bushings in the automotive and machinery sectors are the typical applications of both grades. 16MnCr5 is a common choice in European gearbox and reducer designs; 5115 appears mainly in American drawings for smaller, less heavily loaded parts.
Applications
- Gears and pinions
- Splined shafts
- Piston pins and knuckle pins
- Chain components
- Camshafts and bushings
16MnCr5 or 5115: which to choose and when
If the drawing is to EN or the part has a thick section, choose 16MnCr5; if hardening behaviour matters, write the +H class and a suitable delivery condition (for example +FP) into the order. If a US drawing calls for 5115, supply 5115 to ASTM A29. Using 16MnCr5 instead of 5115 usually causes no technical problem, but the heat-treatment parameters must be re-validated because hardening and distortion behaviour will change. The reverse, 5115 instead of 16MnCr5, may lower the core strength of thick parts. If more hardenability is needed, the next step is 20MnCr5 in EN or the nickel-chromium-molybdenum 8620 on the US side.
Equivalence caveats and ordering notes
5115 is the most frequently quoted American counterpart of 16MnCr5, but it is not an exact equivalent: the manganese ranges do not overlap at all (1.00–1.30% vs 0.70–0.90%), so a single heat cannot meet both chemistries. JIS SCr415 is also only an approximate counterpart. When changing grade, look not at the name alone but at the required surface hardness, case depth and core hardness, and ask for a Jominy curve if needed. The inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1) should show the heat analysis, the delivery condition and, if ordered, the hardenability results.
Grade Equivalents
| System | 16MnCr5 | 5115 |
|---|---|---|
| EN | 16MnCr5 | — |
| DIN (W.Nr.) | 1.7131 | — |
| AISI/SAE | ≈ 5115 | 5115 |
| UNS | — | G51150 |
| JIS | ≈ SCr415 | ≈ SCr415 |
Standards
16MnCr5
- EN 10084
- EN ISO 683-3
5115
- SAE J404
- ASTM A29/A29M
- ASTM A322
The values on this page are reference data compiled from the published limits of the standards named. Binding values are those on the material's inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1), according to the standard and delivery condition stated in the order.
Technical Datasheet
Products made in these grades
Looking for this steel grade?
Request a quote with your sizes, tolerances and delivery condition — we respond within 24 hours.
