S355J2vsA572 Gr.50

EN S355J2 (1.0577) and ASTM A572 Grade 50 are close counterparts: yield 355 vs 345 MPa. S355J2 requires 27 J at −20 °C and a CEV limit; A572 specifies a micro-alloy type and makes impact testing a supplement. Chemistry, values and selection.

Chemical composition: where they differ

S355J2 (1.0577) is a non-alloy structural steel to EN 10025-2; A572 Grade 50 is the high-strength low-alloy (HSLA) columbium-vanadium steel defined in ASTM A572/A572M. By heat analysis, S355J2 allows at most 0.20% carbon (up to 40 mm), 0.55% silicon, 1.60% manganese, 0.025% phosphorus and sulphur and 0.55% copper; the standard also caps the carbon equivalent (CEV at 0.45 up to 30 mm). A572 Grade 50 allows at most 0.23% carbon, 1.35% manganese, 0.40% silicon up to 40 mm, and 0.030% phosphorus and sulphur. What sets A572 apart is micro-alloying: the order specifies a Type, and the Types define combinations of niobium (columbium), vanadium or titanium-nitrogen. EN 10025-2, by contrast, requires no micro-alloying for S355J2.

Chemical Composition

ElementS355J2A572 Gr.50
C≤ 0.20 (t ≤ 40 mm)≤ 0.23
Si≤ 0.55≤ 0.40 (t ≤ 40 mm)
Mn≤ 1.60≤ 1.35
P≤ 0.025≤ 0.030
S≤ 0.025≤ 0.030
Cu≤ 0.55—
CEV≤ 0.45 (t ≤ 30 mm)—

Heat (cast) analysis, % by mass.

Basis: S355J2 — EN 10025-2A572 Gr.50 — ASTM A572/A572M

—: the designation sets no value for this property, or no comparable value is given here. The binding value follows the product standard, the delivery condition and the order, and is stated on the inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1).

Mechanical properties and strength

The difference in yield strength is small: S355J2 requires at least 355 MPa up to 16 mm, falling step by step with thickness (345 MPa at 16–40 mm), while A572 Grade 50 requires at least 345 MPa (50 ksi). Tensile strength for S355J2 is 470–630 MPa from 3 to 100 mm; A572 Grade 50 has only a lower limit (at least 450 MPa). Elongation values cannot be compared directly because they are measured on different gauge lengths: EN uses a proportional gauge length (L0 = 5.65√S0), A572 uses 200 mm and 50 mm. The key difference is toughness: the J2 class of S355J2 means at least 27 J Charpy-V impact energy at −20 °C. In A572 impact testing is not mandatory; if needed, it is ordered as a supplementary requirement together with the temperature and energy value.

Mechanical Properties

PropertyS355J2A572 Gr.50
Yield Strength (MPa)≥ 355≥ 345
Tensile Strength (MPa)470–630≥ 450
Elongation (%)≥ 22 (L0 = 5.65√S0)≥ 18 (L0 = 200 mm)
Impact Energy (J) at −20 °C≥ 27—

Basis: S355J2 — +AR / +N · t ≤ 16 mm · EN 10025-2A572 Gr.50 — ASTM A572/A572M

—: the designation sets no value for this property, or no comparable value is given here. The binding value follows the product standard, the delivery condition and the order, and is stated on the inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1).

Heat treatment and delivery conditions

Both steels gain their strength from chemistry and rolling conditions, not from heat treatment. S355J2 can be delivered as-rolled (+AR) or normalised / normalised-rolled (+N); thermomechanically rolled versions are defined separately in EN 10025-4 as S355M. A572 usually comes as-rolled; the micro-alloying elements raise strength by refining grain size and by precipitation hardening. Welded structures can be stress relieved where needed, but because long holding at high temperature can reduce strength, especially in thermomechanical steels, the standard and design requirements must be followed.

Weldability and machinability

Weldability is good for both grades, and both are widely welded in steel fabrication. The CEV limit of S355J2 makes the need for preheating in thick sections more predictable. A572 Grade 50 has no CEV limit in the standard, so for thick parts the welding procedure must be based on the actual heat analysis and on an application code such as AWS D1.1. Cold bending and forming are possible for both; the bend radius should be chosen according to thickness and rolling direction. In machining they behave like soft, ductile structural steels.

Typical applications

Both grades are the main material for medium- and heavy-load steel construction: load-bearing frames of buildings and industrial structures, bridges, cranes and lifting equipment, towers and masts, machine frames, pipe supports and platforms. S355J2 is preferred for outdoor structures and dynamically loaded constructions because it guarantees toughness at low temperature. In the USA, wide-flange shapes are mostly ASTM A992 and bridges use ASTM A709 Grade 50, while A572 Grade 50 is common in plate, flat bar and other sections.

Applications

  • Load-bearing frames of buildings and industrial structures
  • Bridges and crane structures
  • Towers, masts and platforms
  • Machine frames and heavy fabrication
  • Pipe supports and steelwork connections

S355J2 or A572 Gr.50: which to choose and when

If the project is designed to Eurocode and EN 1090 and CE-marked fabrication is required, choose S355J2 (or JR, J0 or K2 according to the toughness needed); projects based on AISC and ASTM call for A572 Grade 50. Using S355J2 instead of A572 Grade 50 is usually no problem in terms of strength, and the impact requirement adds assurance. In the opposite case, using A572 instead of S355J2, the −20 °C impact test must be ordered as a supplementary requirement and the CEV must be checked. For thicker plates and lower service temperatures, normalised or thermomechanical grades such as S355NL or S355ML are considered.

Equivalence caveats and ordering notes

S355J2 and A572 Grade 50 are close counterparts, not exact equivalents: the yield value, tensile range, manganese limit, micro-alloying requirement, elongation measurement method and, above all, the impact requirement differ. Dual-certified material meeting both standards is available on the market; in that case, check that the inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1) shows the chemical and mechanical results for both standards, the −20 °C impact test for S355J2 and the Type for A572. The old DIN name is St 52-3 N; JIS SM490 and the GB Q355 series are only approximate counterparts. In the order, state the standard, grade, thickness, delivery condition and, if needed, the impact test temperature.

Grade Equivalents

SystemS355J2A572 Gr.50
ENS355J2—
DIN (W.Nr.)1.0577—
DIN 17100St 52-3 N—
ASTM≈ A572 Gr.50A572 Gr.50
JIS≈ SM490B—
GB (China)≈ Q355D—

Standards

S355J2

  • EN 10025-1
  • EN 10025-2

A572 Gr.50

  • ASTM A572/A572M
  • ASME SA-572

The values on this page are reference data compiled from the published limits of the standards named. Binding values are those on the material's inspection certificate (EN 10204 3.1), according to the standard and delivery condition stated in the order.

Looking for this steel grade?

Request a quote with your sizes, tolerances and delivery condition — we respond within 24 hours.

Request a Quote