Spring Steel Guide: 51CrV4, 60Si7, 55Cr3 and 65G Compared
Spring steel is the steel class that delivers a high elastic limit after quenching and tempering. We compare 51CrV4, 55Cr3, 56Si7 and 61SiCr7 from EN 10089, the old DIN name 60Si7 and the GOST grade 65G by chemistry, heat treatment, equivalents and selection criteria.
📋 51CrV4 Datasheet → — chemical composition, section-dependent mechanical values and equivalents. For how spring steels relate to quenched and tempered steels: Q&T Steels Guide →
What Is Spring Steel?
Spring steel is the class of steel used for parts that must deflect under load and return to their original shape, without permanent set, once the load is removed. The property that makes this possible is a high elastic limit: the yield strength of the material must sit well above the working stress of the spring. That is why spring steels have a relatively high carbon content (roughly 0.5–0.7% C), are alloyed with silicon, chromium, manganese or vanadium, and are used quenched and tempered after the part has been formed.
For springs made from hot-rolled bar and flat, the European standard is EN 10089 (hot-rolled steels for quenched and tempered springs). It replaced the old German standard DIN 17221. In Russia and the CIS the same job is done by GOST 14959. Fine spring wire (the EN 10270 series) and cold-rolled spring strip (EN 10132-4) are covered by separate standards; this article deals with spring steels in bar and flat form.
Four Names, Four Alloy Families
The four names in the title actually stand for four different alloying approaches. The table below puts the current EN 10089 names side by side with the old and international designations:
| Grade | Material No. | Standard | Alloy family | Close equivalents |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 51CrV4 | 1.8159 | EN 10089 / EN 10083-3 | Chromium-vanadium | AISI 6150, JIS SUP10, GOST ≈ 50KhFA (50ХФА) |
| 55Cr3 | 1.7176 | EN 10089 | Chromium | AISI/SAE 5155, 5160; GOST ≈ 50KhGA (50ХГА) |
| 56Si7 | 1.5026 | EN 10089 | Silicon | BS 250A53, 250A58 |
| 61SiCr7 | 1.7108 | EN 10089 | Silicon-chromium | ≈ SAE 9260; called 60SiCr7 in DIN 17221 |
| 60Si7 | 1.5027 | DIN 17221 / EU 89 (withdrawn) | Silicon | Closest in EN 10089: 56Si7, 61SiCr7 |
| 65G (65Г) | — | GOST 14959 | Manganese | AISI 1566, GB 65Mn |
ℹ️ About 60Si7: 60Si7 (1.5027) is a silicon spring steel name from the DIN 17221 era that is still widely used in trade. If you order to EN 10089, which replaced DIN 17221, the closest grades are 56Si7 (slightly lower carbon) and 61SiCr7 (a small chromium addition for higher hardenability). Ask for the quotation and the certificate to state which standard the material was made to. The silicon counterpart in Russia and the CIS is the 60S2 / 60S2A (60С2 / 60С2А) family.
Chemical Composition Compared
| Element (%) | 51CrV4 | 55Cr3 | 56Si7 | 61SiCr7 | 65G |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C | 0.47–0.55 | 0.52–0.59 | 0.52–0.60 | 0.57–0.65 | 0.62–0.70 |
| Si | ≤ 0.40 | ≤ 0.40 | 1.60–2.00 | 1.60–2.00 | 0.17–0.37 |
| Mn | 0.70–1.10 | 0.70–1.00 | 0.60–0.90 | 0.70–1.00 | 0.90–1.20 |
| Cr | 0.90–1.20 | 0.70–1.00 | — | 0.20–0.45 | ≤ 0.25 |
| V | 0.10–0.25 | — | — | — | — |
Sources: EN 10089 (51CrV4, 55Cr3, 56Si7, 61SiCr7) and GOST 14959 (65G). EN 10089 additionally limits phosphorus and sulphur to ≤ 0.025% for 51CrV4, 55Cr3 and 61SiCr7; GOST 14959 gives P and S ≤ 0.035% for 65G.
Two conclusions follow from the table. First, the carbon window is narrow and high: every grade starts above 0.47%, which means high as-quenched hardness and high yield strength. Second, the real difference comes from the second element: silicon (56Si7, 61SiCr7), chromium (55Cr3), chromium plus vanadium (51CrV4) or manganese alone (65G). To check an incoming mill certificate against these ranges, use our Chemical Composition tool.
What Does Each Alloying Element Add?
- Silicon (Si): Strengthens the ferrite and raises the elastic limit and the resistance to sag (relaxation), so a spring keeps its free height better under long-term load. The price is twofold: hardenability is limited, and the tendency to surface decarburisation during heat treatment increases. A spring with a decarburised surface cracks from the surface in fatigue.
- Chromium (Cr): Raises hardenability and helps thicker leaves and stabiliser bars harden through to the core. 55Cr3 is also requested as the European counterpart of the American SAE 5160.
- Chromium + vanadium (51CrV4): Chromium brings hardenability, vanadium brings a fine grain structure and toughness. It is the grade with the highest hardenability in this group and is preferred for thick leaf springs, torsion bars and heavy-duty springs. 51CrV4 is also a quenched and tempered steel in EN 10083-3.
- Manganese (65G): Raises the hardenability of a non-alloy spring steel with manganese alone. It is economical and common for washers, circlips, flat springs and small-section round springs.
Heat Treatment and Reference Values
In spring steel, strength does not come from a single figure in the standard but from heat treatment: the part (leaf, coil, torsion bar) is formed first, then quenched and tempered to the target hardness. The values below are reference values given by their sources; the final process is set by the spring maker according to the target hardness.
| Grade | Hardening | Tempering | Reference result | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 51CrV4 | 850–880 °C, oil | Depends on application | ~44–50 HRC in spring applications | Our 51CrV4 datasheet |
| 56Si7 | 860 °C, oil | 450 °C | Max. 248 HB soft annealed | EN 10089 (Annex D, Table 6) |
| 65G | 830 °C, oil | 470 °C | Yield ≥ 785 MPa, tensile ≥ 980 MPa, elongation ≥ 8% | GOST 14959 |
For 55Cr3, the binding values are set by the certificate of the supplied heat and by the spring maker's process. To convert hardness to tensile strength, use our Hardness Converter: for example, 44–50 HRC corresponds to roughly 1400–1680 MPa tensile strength. For the general logic of quenching and tempering, see our Steel Heat Treatment Processes Guide.
Which One to Choose? A Decision Guide
Choose 51CrV4 if:
- The section is thick (heavy leaves, large-diameter torsion bars) and through-hardening to the core is required
- Impact and fatigue loading are both demanding
- You want to use the same material for springs and for Q&T parts (shafts, gears)
Choose 55Cr3 if:
- You make leaf springs or stabiliser bars
- Your drawing or customer calls for SAE 5160 and you need the EN equivalent
Choose 56Si7 / 61SiCr7 (formerly 60Si7) if:
- Sag resistance is the priority in coil and leaf springs
- The section is thin to medium (61SiCr7 reaches slightly thicker sections thanks to chromium)
- Your heat treatment line can control surface decarburisation
Choose 65G if:
- The part has a small section (washer, flat spring, circlip) and cost is decisive
- You produce for a market that works to GOST (Russia, CIS)
What to Write in the Order Specification
- Grade and standard — e.g. "51CrV4, EN 10089"; if you order under an old name (60Si7), also state the standard equivalent.
- Form and size — round bar (EN 10060), hot-rolled spring steel flats (EN 10092-1) or forged bar; length and tolerance.
- Delivery condition — as rolled or soft annealed (+A); choose +A if the material will be cold formed or machined.
- Surface and decarburisation — for springs working in fatigue, state the permitted depth of the decarburised layer.
- Inspection document — EN 10204 3.1, reporting the heat analysis and the hardness in the delivery condition.
Can Spring Steels Be Welded?
Welding is not recommended. The high carbon and alloy content forms hard, brittle martensite in the heat-affected zone, and at the stress levels a spring works at, that zone becomes a crack initiation site. Producer datasheets also rate 56Si7 as unsuitable for welding. In our article Carbon Equivalent and Weldability we calculated the carbon equivalent grade by grade: with a mid-range analysis, 51CrV4 has a CEV of about 0.9.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is 51CrV4 the same steel as SAE 5160?
No. The American equivalent of 51CrV4 is AISI 6150 (chromium-vanadium). SAE 5160 is a chromium spring steel without vanadium; its closest counterpart in EN 10089 is 55Cr3.
What is the EN 10089 equivalent of 60Si7?
60Si7 is the old DIN 17221 name. The closest grades in EN 10089 are 56Si7 (1.5026) and 61SiCr7 (1.7108); which one fits depends on the section thickness and the hardenability you need.
What is the equivalent of 65G steel?
65G (65Г) is the manganese spring steel of GOST 14959 and is compared with AISI 1566 and the Chinese grade 65Mn. The "G" in its name stands for the raised manganese content: with 0.90–1.20% Mn it differs from the non-alloy steel 65, which has 0.50–0.80% Mn.
What hardness is spring steel used at?
It depends on the application. For 51CrV4, about 44–50 HRC is typical in spring applications; when it is used as a Q&T component, it is tempered to a lower hardness and higher toughness.
Supply from Aktif Çelik
We supply 51CrV4 as hot-rolled bar, flat bar and forged bar, with an EN 10204 3.1 inspection certificate. For 55Cr3, 56Si7, 61SiCr7 (60Si7) and 65G, simply send us the grade, size, quantity and the standard you need: we confirm availability with the producers in our supply network and send a written quotation. You can look up the international equivalents of each grade in our Steel Grade Equivalents tool.
🔗 See also: Steel Equivalence Tables · Downloads
Detailed Technical Info & Quotation
Contact our expert team for detailed technical documents, application recommendations, and custom dimension quotes on this topic.

