Multi-pass weld bead joining thick structural steel plates, with a preheating torch flame
TechnicalAnalysis

Carbon Equivalent and Weldability: How to Calculate CEV, CET and Pcm

Aktif Çelik Technical Team8 min read

The carbon equivalent reduces a steel's chemical analysis to a single number that indicates the risk of cold cracking and the need for preheat in welding. We collected the CEV, CET and Pcm formulas, the standards that use them and calculated values for 12 common grades in one table.

🧮 Carbon Equivalent calculator → — calculate CEV, CET and Pcm from your own analysis.

📋 To check a chemical analysis against the standard ranges: Chemical Composition tool → · Structural steels: S235JR datasheet · S355J2 datasheet

What Is the Carbon Equivalent?

The carbon equivalent (CE) is a calculation that expresses the hardening effect of carbon and the alloying elements in a steel as a single figure in terms of carbon. During welding the heat-affected zone (HAZ) heats and cools quickly; if the steel's hardenability is high, hard and brittle martensite forms there. When that structure meets diffusible hydrogen from the weld metal and stresses in the joint, cold (hydrogen) cracking occurs — often hours after welding.

The carbon equivalent shows the material's share of that risk: the higher the value, the higher the cracking risk and the required preheat temperature. Preheating slows the cooling, which both limits the formation of hard structures and gives hydrogen time to escape from the joint.

Three Formulas, Three Fields of Use

FormulaEquation (wt %)Where it is used
CEV (IIW)C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15As a maximum value for EN 10025 structural steels; input to one of the preheat methods in EN 1011-2
CETC + (Mn + Mo)/10 + (Cr + Cu)/20 + Ni/40Method B of EN 1011-2: preheat temperature calculated together with thickness, hydrogen and heat input
Pcm (Ito–Bessyo)C + Si/30 + (Mn + Cu + Cr)/20 + Ni/60 + Mo/15 + V/10 + 5BLow-carbon steels; in API 5L PSL 2 line pipe, CE(Pcm) applies when carbon ≤ 0.12%, CE(IIW) above that

CET is valid only within a defined composition range (wt %): C 0.05–0.32 · Si ≤ 0.8 · Mn 0.5–1.9 · Cr ≤ 1.5 · Cu ≤ 0.7 · Mo ≤ 0.75 · Nb ≤ 0.06 · Ni ≤ 2.5 · Ti ≤ 0.12 · V ≤ 0.18 · B ≤ 0.005. For steels outside this range, the CET-based preheat calculation is not used.

Worked Example: CEV from an S355J2 Certificate

Example heat analysis (not a real certificate): C 0.16 · Si 0.25 · Mn 1.45 · Cr 0.05 · Mo 0.01 · V 0.005 · Ni 0.04 · Cu 0.03.

  • CEV = 0.16 + 1.45/6 + (0.05 + 0.01 + 0.005)/5 + (0.04 + 0.03)/15 = 0.160 + 0.242 + 0.013 + 0.005 = 0.42
  • CET = 0.16 + (1.45 + 0.01)/10 + (0.05 + 0.03)/20 + 0.04/40 = 0.160 + 0.146 + 0.004 + 0.001 = 0.31
  • Pcm = 0.16 + 0.25/30 + (1.45 + 0.03 + 0.05)/20 + 0.04/60 + 0.01/15 + 0.005/10 = 0.25

Result: a CEV of 0.42 is within the 0.45 limit that EN 10025-2 sets for S355 up to 30 mm thickness. The standard defines this limit on the heat (ladle) analysis; if the value is not printed on the certificate, it can be calculated from the analysis this way.

12 Grades Compared

The table below shows values we calculated from the standard ranges in our datasheets. Basis of calculation: midpoint of each range; half the limit for Si given as "≤"; the residual limits for Cr, Mo and Ni in C45, as well as V, Cu and B, taken as zero. Actual values depend on the heat analysis; the table is for comparison and does not replace the certificate.

GradeC (mid)CEVCETPcmPractical comment
S235JR≤ 0.17≤ 0.35 *——Usually no preheat in thin and medium sections
S355J2≤ 0.20≤ 0.45 *——Welds well; thick, restrained joints may need preheat
C150.150.23— **0.18Easy to weld
16MnCr50.1650.550.330.28Preheat required
86200.200.510.340.29Preheat required
20MnCr50.1950.630.380.32Preheat and controlled cooling
25CrMo40.2550.640.41—Preheat required; the easiest to weld of the alloy Q&T steels
C450.460.57— **—Preheat required; stress relief after welding in thick sections
39NiCrMo30.390.76— **—Difficult; needs a qualified welding procedure
42CrMo40.4150.80— **—Difficult; our datasheet recommends 200–300 °C preheat, low-hydrogen electrodes, ~550–650 °C stress relief
34CrNiMo60.340.89— **—Difficult; needs a qualified welding procedure
51CrV40.510.91— **—Welding not recommended (spring steel)

* Maximum CEV given by EN 10025-2 for thicknesses up to 30 mm (heat analysis); the permitted value rises with thickness (e.g. 0.38 for S235JR above 40 mm). ** The composition is outside the CET validity range (C > 0.32% or Mn < 0.5%). The Pcm column is limited to the low-carbon grades the formula was developed for.

Two conclusions follow. First, case-hardening steels have a CEV above 0.5 despite their low carbon (16MnCr5, 20MnCr5) because of manganese and chromium; the rule "low carbon = easy welding" is misleading on its own. Second, in Q&T steels the CEV quickly exceeds 0.8; these grades are designed for heat-treated machine parts, not for welded structures.

How to Interpret the Number

The exact preheat temperature does not follow from the carbon equivalent alone. The methods in EN 1011-2 consider four inputs together:

  1. Carbon equivalent (CEV or CET depending on the method)
  2. Combined thickness — the sum of all sections through which heat escapes; a thick joint cools faster
  3. Diffusible hydrogen (HD) — set by the choice of consumable and process (ml/100 g); low-hydrogen consumables reduce the risk
  4. Heat input (kJ/mm) — higher heat input slows cooling

In practice, the following rough CEV bands are used; they are general guidance and do not replace a welding procedure:

CEVGeneral assessment
≤ 0.40Good weldability; usually no preheat in thin and medium sections
0.40–0.50Preheat may be needed depending on thickness, hydrogen level and restraint
> 0.50Preheat, low-hydrogen consumables and controlled interpass temperature are required; post-weld heat treatment is considered

Checking the Carbon Equivalent on a Certificate

  • Base your check on the heat analysis in the EN 10204 3.1 inspection certificate.
  • For structural steels (S275, S355) the maximum CEV is defined in the standard; if you are welding, you can state a maximum CEV explicitly in the order.
  • If Cu, Ni or V are not reported on the certificate, the CEV calculation is incomplete; ask for a full analysis.
  • To compare the analysis with the standard ranges use the Chemical Composition tool; for international equivalents of the grade use Steel Grade Equivalents.

Which Grade Suits Welded Fabrication?

  • Weld-intensive structures: S235JR and S355J2 — low CEV and a limit guaranteed by the standard. For a comparison, see our article S235 vs S355.
  • A high-strength part that must be welded: among Q&T steels, 25CrMo4 (AISI 4130) is the most suitable thanks to its lower carbon; details in 4130 vs 4140.
  • Q&T and spring steels: high-CEV grades such as 42CrMo4, 34CrNiMo6 and 51CrV4 need a procedure and heat treatment for welding; for spring steels welding is not recommended at all. See our Spring Steel Guide.
  • Flange and pipe connections: weld neck flanges are welded to the pipe, so material choice and the analysis on the certificate matter; see our flange products.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a carbon equivalent of 0.45 mean?

A CEV of 0.45 is the maximum EN 10025-2 permits for S355 up to 30 mm thickness. At this level the steel generally welds well; thick and restrained joints, or processes with high hydrogen, may need preheat.

What is the difference between CEV and CET?

CEV is the IIW formula and is used for the standard limits of structural steels. CET is used in method B of EN 1011-2 to calculate the preheat temperature together with thickness, hydrogen and heat input, and is valid only within a defined composition range.

When is Pcm used?

Pcm was developed to assess cold-cracking susceptibility in low-carbon steels. API 5L applies the CE(Pcm) limit to PSL 2 line pipe with carbon of 0.12% or less, and the CE(IIW) limit above that.

Can a steel with a high carbon equivalent never be welded?

It can, but conditionally: with appropriate preheat, low-hydrogen consumables, controlled interpass temperature and post-weld heat treatment where needed. These conditions should be set by a qualified welding procedure.

Supply from Aktif Çelik

For welded fabrication we supply structural and alloy steels as hot rolled bars, carbon steel and flanges, with an EN 10204 3.1 inspection certificate that includes the heat analysis. If your order has a requirement such as a maximum CEV, put it in your request for quotation; we confirm a compliant heat with the producers in our supply network.

🔗 See also: Quality & Certificates · Steel Equivalence Tables

Request a quote →

Detailed Technical Info & Quotation

Contact our expert team for detailed technical documents, application recommendations, and custom dimension quotes on this topic.

Get a Quote